Brazil backs Bolsanaro: what next?
Despite his controversial reputation, Jair Bolsanaro’s victory in the Brazilian election has been greeted with investor optimism. But the real test is yet to come – particularly regarding the crucial topic of pension reform.
29 October 2018
The will and ability to reform
Financial markets, at least, had been rooting for a defeat of the left-wing candidate Fernando Haddad, successor to former president Lula, on the basis of the very different economic policies espoused by the two candidates. Superficially, this seems odd given that Bolsonaro has repeatedly voted against reform and spoken out against privatisation - he once said former president Fernando Henrique Cardoso should be shot for privatising iron ore miner Vale. However, in his presidential run this is one stance he did moderate, appointing pro-market Paulo Guedes as his economic advisor and now minister. Haddad, meanwhile, remained staunchly anti-reform, anti-privatisation and in favour of more spending.
However, we still have some concerns around Bolsonaro's Damascene conversion to the cause of free markets. Guedes is not the only adviser he has, and others on his team oppose the ultra-liberal stance Guedes takes, particularly on privatisation. Meanwhile, other key figures, including his likely chief of staff and one of his four senators, seem strongly opposed to desperately needed pension reform.
On top of these internal divisions, Bolsonaro must also contend with a fragmented legislature. This is a cause for concern, given Bolsonaro's limited ability as a political operator; he will need to draw allies with skill in negotiating the legislative process.
The need to reform
Brazil's largest single economic problem at present is its fiscal position. Government debt-to-GDP is remarkably high by emerging markets (EM) standards at 84%, and is set to climb further thanks to sizeable deficits (7.8% of GDP in 2017, including interest payments) with the International Monetary Fund projecting gross debt to hit 95.6% in 2023.
Brazil's debt problem is projected to deteriorate
Source: IMF, Thomson Datastream, Schroders Economics Group. 24 October 2018
The lion's share of Brazil's budget expenditure is taken up by social security benefits, particularly pensions; a problem which grew notably under Dilma's government. As has been highlighted in The Economist and elsewhere, Brazilian expenditure on pensions is as high as that seen in Europe, despite wildly different incomes and demographics. Pension reform is therefore key to addressing Brazil's dire fiscal outlook. In its recent Article IV consultation, the IMF argued that to stabilise pension spending as a share of GDP, reform would need to increase retirement ages, de-link the minimum pension from the minimum wage, and reduce the generosity of public sector pensions in particular (80% of pension payments currently go to the public sector).
Government spending is large and hard to cut
Source: Thomson Datastream, Schroders Economics Group. 24 October 2018
It would also be helpful to reduce payroll expenditure, simplify the tax code (particularly by reducing exemptions) and tackle the broader problem of mandatory expenditures. Pension reform though is key as being symbolic of intent, as well as the largest single ticket item of expenditure.
Market and macro implications
Bolsonaro's apparent embrace of economic liberalism has been key in changing attitudes from investors. Business confidence in particular has rebounded from its lows this year, which should be positive for investment, while Brazilian assets have seen a resurgence of interest, in part because they offer a rare good news story in a torrid year for EM.
Bolsonaro bolsters Brazilian sentiment
Source: Thomson Datastream, Schroders Economics Group. 25 October 2018
It seems likely that this initial optimism could extend to euphoria for a while. Assuming no unforced errors on the part of Bolsonaro, the first reality check for investors is likely to come in the second quarter of 2019, when a post-Carnival legislature comes to the practicalities of passing tough bills (legislative recess will begin on 22 December and end only on the 4 February, one month before Carnival). Until that point, markets should feed largely on the signals sent by the incoming president. Signs that Guedes is being side-lined (or that the corruption investigation could remove him) or that Bolsonaro is finding it harder than expected to build an allied legislative base, could knock the rally off course. On the other side, should Bolsonaro manage to attract experienced political names, this would further raise the perceived odds of passing tough reforms, given his own limited legislative experience (he has co-authored only two pieces of legislation in a near 30-year long career).
On the macroeconomic side, the sheer relief at having avoided a leftist government should see a lot of deferred investments finally break ground. Currency strength after a period of weakness will also help calm nerves on inflation and the direction of interest rates. We would expect economic growth to begin accelerating, which should also have the effect of boosting Bolsonaro's political capital at a crucial moment.
For now though the Brazilian story seems a good one. We will keep an eye on Bolsonaro for signs of wavering policy intent, or even a preference for prioritising social legislation over fiscal issues. Should he fail to deliver, a sharp unwind seems likely, with particular pain in the fixed income space given the extremely challenging fiscal outlook.
The fund manager view
Pablo Riveroll, Head of Latin American Equities:
“Pension reform and ongoing fiscal discipline is deemed to be critical to medium-term fiscal sustainability in Brazil. The performance of Brazilian assets is likely to depend on the extent to which the Bolsanaro administration delivers appropriate policy measures. Should the government fail to pursue sufficiently conventional economic policies, it is likely that the bond and currency market reaction would pressure the government to consider a more orthodox policy framework. As a result, we have conviction that fiscal sustainability will be addressed in the medium term.
“From an investment perspective, we have a cautiously positive view on Brazilian equities. The market is trading at attractive valuations, with a forward price-to-earnings ratio of around 10x, which is a discount to wider emerging markets and to its history, with above average earnings growth. We believe that pension reform is likely to be approved by the new government. The market may be vulnerable if it does not commit to presenting and passing pension reform at the beginning of its administration. We aim to take advantage of market volatility to add to high quality Brazilian companies at discounted valuations if our base case scenario plays out.”
Important Information: This communication is marketing material. The views and opinions contained herein are those of the author(s) on this page, and may not necessarily represent views expressed or reflected in other Schroders communications, strategies or funds. This material is intended to be for information purposes only and is not intended as promotional material in any respect. The material is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. It is not intended to provide and should not be relied on for accounting, legal or tax advice, or investment recommendations. Reliance should not be placed on the views and information in this document when taking individual investment and/or strategic decisions. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. The value of an investment can go down as well as up and is not guaranteed. All investments involve risks including the risk of possible loss of principal. Information herein is believed to be reliable but Schroders does not warrant its completeness or accuracy. Some information quoted was obtained from external sources we consider to be reliable. No responsibility can be accepted for errors of fact obtained from third parties, and this data may change with market conditions. This does not exclude any duty or liability that Schroders has to its customers under any regulatory system. Regions/ sectors shown for illustrative purposes only and should not be viewed as a recommendation to buy/sell. The opinions in this material include some forecasted views. We believe we are basing our expectations and beliefs on reasonable assumptions within the bounds of what we currently know. However, there is no guarantee than any forecasts or opinions will be realised. These views and opinions may change. To the extent that you are in North America, this content is issued by Schroder Investment Management North America Inc., an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of Schroders plc and SEC registered adviser providing asset management products and services to clients in the US and Canada. For all other users, this content is issued by Schroder Investment Management Limited, 1 London Wall Place, London EC2Y 5AU. Registered No. 1893220 England. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.